חומר רקע
Prevention and Means of Handling:
Sexual Harassment towards Workers
in the Home Nursing Sector
January, 2022
Definition
Sexual harassment is a violation of human dignity, liberty,
privacy and the right to equality.
Sexual harassment can take various forms, from indecent acts
to abasement and humiliation based on sex.
Sexual harassment is a criminal offense punishable by
imprisonment, and in addition, the injured party can file an
action for compensation against the harasser (s. 6 of the
Prevention of Sexual Harassment Law, 5748-1988).
Sexual harassment is also prohibited in the workplace, and the
employer has an obligation to ensure that the work environment
is safe and protected.
Under s. 3 of the law, sexual harassment is any of the following
acts:
1.Blackmailing a person by threats to carry out an act of a
sexual nature
Blackmail by threats is of a sexual nature where the act that the
employer is required to do under blackmail is of a sexual
character. For example: "If you refuse to get dressed in my
presence, I will not pay you this month".
2.An indecent act
An indecent act is an act committed for sexual arousal and/or
satisfaction. For example: touching intimate body parts.
3.Repeated propositions of a sexual nature
For example: repeated propositions to give a massage,
repeated propositions to have sexual intercourse.
4.Repeated references to a person's sexuality
Such references can be made in writing, orally, with pictures,
by means of a computer, and by behavior. For example: "Your
smell is driving me wild".
5.Humiliating or degrading reference of a sexual nature
Degrading
references
include
degrading
or
humiliating
references attr to the caregiver with respect to her gender,
sexuality or sexual inclination. For example: "All caregivers like
to be touched".
6.Publishing a picture, a video or a recording of a person,
while focusing on his sexuality, in circumstances in which
the publication is liable to humiliate or degrade him,
without that person's consent
For example: photographing the caregiver while in the shower
and distributing the photograph.
7.Exploitation of authority relations in sexual harassment
Authority relations are relations where one party is able to
exercise control and exploit his power over the other party. For
example: a relationship between the patient's relative who is in
charge of paying the caregiver's wage, and the caregiver.
8.Adverse treatment
Adverse treatment is any harmful act, the source of which is
sexual harassment or a complaint of sexual harassment. For
example: an employer dismisses an employee based on her
refusal to accept propositions of a sexual nature.
Complexities in the nursing sector
In the home nursing sector, most of the employed workers are
foreign workers. As of the time of publishing, over 60,000 women
and men (the overbearing majority of which are women) are
employed in Israel under a work permit and live at their employer's
home, or at the home of their patient's family. The number of
workers in this sector is even expected to rise significantly, in view
of the increase of life expectancy in Israel, and the preference to
grow old at home, together with the lack of Israeli workers who are
interested in working in this sector.
The home nursing sector is one of many complexities and
sensitivities. Even more so in matters concerning the issue of sexual
harassment: foreign caregiving workers perform "one on one" work,
live with the patient who is their employer, and are with him in
sensitive and intimate situations. Such workers depend on the
patient for their livelihood, accommodation and continued stay in
Israel.
In many cases, the worker is also dependent upon the patient's
family members, and therefore is even more broadly exposed and
vulnerable. To this is added another difficulty, which is under-
reporting of sexual harassment complaints. This stems from the
worker's financial dependency upon the patient, but also from the
worker's need to maintain her routine daily life with the employer,
which directly impacts her set of considerations when deciding
whether
or
not
to
complain
when
she
experiences
sexual
harassment.
Notwithstanding, we should once again clarify: sexual harassment is
prohibited and must not be tolerated.
What can be done if you are
harassed at the workplace?
Emergency hotline for women: 1202
Emergency hotline for men: 1203
Workers who wish to complain against employers have several
options:
1.The worker must first report any violation to the private
recruitment agency with which she is registered. The private
recruitment agency has a social worker acting on its behalf, who
undergoes appropriate training for handling sensitive cases, and who
is familiar with the worker and the patient.
S. 6.3.16 of the "Private Agency Procedure for Bringing, Recruitment
and Care of Foreign Caregivers" (Procedure No. 9.2.001 of the
Population and Immigration Authority) refers, inter alia, to cases
where there is a suspicion of sexual harassment, and imposes a
reporting obligation upon the social worker and the general manager
of the private agency. In such cases, the private agency shall
proceed to examine the complaint, according to the instructions of
the social worker in charge, and in the appropriate cases, it shall
visit the patient's house and handle the complaint in accordance with
the law.
2.You can contact the Commissioner for Foreign Workers' Labor
Rights Unit (the service we provide is state-provided and free of
charge).
3.You can contact the Association of Rape Crisis Centers in
Israel:
Emergency hotline for Arab women: 04-6566813
Assistance via WhatsApp: 052-8361202
4.If you are a victim of sexual assault you are entitled to medical
treatment, free of charge and regardless of your status. Victims
are entitled to treatment in 7 dedicated acute rooms in general
hospitals. Dedicated teams, who have undergone training in the area
of sexual trauma, operate in these rooms, and they provide
personally tailored and sensitive treatment. These rooms provide
year-round 24/7 response, and are intended for both children and
adults.
Location of the acute rooms*:
*The Lobby for War on Sexual Violence.
The roles of the private recruitment
agencies in the prevention and
handling of sexual harassment at
the workplace
The private agencies have a significant role in the handling of
sexual harassment, and also in the prevention thereof. The
following are some measures that can be taken in order to
handle, prevent and/or identify scenarios that may be harmful:
1.During routine visits, the social worker, in every meeting with the
worker, must have a private conversation with her, without the
employer and/or a family member or other representative of the
employer. It is important to note that meeting the worker without the
employer and/or any of their relatives provides the worker with a
safe
and
protected
space
in
which
they
can
complain.
We
recommend that during this conversation the worker receive an
information sheet, in their own language. In addition, the worker
must be asked specifically if they have suffered any sexual violations
by the employer and/or any of their relatives, and the worker's rights
must be explained to her.
2.As aforementioned, workers who are harmed at work do not only
lose their source of income but also their accommodation. Therefore,
private agencies can assist in finding alternative accommodation for
any worker who is harmed at work and is therefore forced to leave.
3.Agencies who wish to acquire tools for identifying and dealing with
the problem of sexual harassment can apply to persons and bodies
who provide training and guidance on sexual offenses committed by
employers against their employees, or join such guidance sessions,
which are held, from time to time, by the Commissioner for Foreign
Workers' Labor Rights Unit, as part of the 'Nursing Workers' Rights
Trustees Project'.
4.We should once again state – for home nursing workers, the
workplace is also where they live. It is important to preserve these
workers' safety and protection, to prevent high-risk situations at the
outset, and to provide assistance, if needed, without delay.